PETER'S POLAR PARLOR

  Six Decades...

One Tasty Tradition!

Six Decades. One Tasty Tradition.

3345 MILTON AVE • FAIRMOUNT

A black t-shirt with a heart on it.

We Got Some Sweet Merch!

T-SHIRTS  •  CAPS  •  MUGS & MORE

BROWSE THE SHOP
A black and white silhouette of a baseball cap on a white background.
A black and white icon of an alarm clock on a white background.

HOURS

SUNDAY - THURSDAY

11:30am to 9:30pm

FRIDAY + SATURDAY

11:30am to 10pm

A black map pin with a circle in the middle on a white background.

LOCATION

3345 Milton Ave • Fairmount
Just Minutes from Costco

OPEN GOOGLE MAPS
A black and white icon of a phone in a speech bubble.

CONTACT

Got questions?

Check out our FAQ, or...

CLICK TO CALL
A car is parked in front of a restaurant with people sitting at picnic tables.

60 Years of Peter's!

Peters Polar Parlor was built in 1969 by Peter DeVoria who ran the business until it was sold in 1986 to Lou Flask. It was acquired by Peter Haun in 2001, who ran it until he retired in 2023. Enter the Penizotto family, who also owns and operates both Big Dip of North Syracuse and Sno-Top of Manlius. Sisters Jacquie and Allison along with help from the rest of the Penizotto family manage day-today operations, carrying on the torch of this beloved Syracuse treasure.

WANNA WORK AT PETER'S?

THE FLAVORS

CLICK TO EXPAND

  • Soft Ice Cream

    Kiddie        $3.01  •  Small     $3.89

    Medium    $4.49  •  Large     $5.88


    Vanilla +  Chocolate

    Pistachio +  Old Fashioned Custard

    Black Raspberry + Raspberry Dole

    Blueberry + Lemon Dole

    Vanilla + Orange Dole


    Try a twist with any paired flavor!

    Try maple or pumpkin in season

    Dole Whips are DAIRY-FREE!!


    Sugar Cone 75¢ • Waffle $1.40

    Sprinkles $1.10 • Krunch Kote  $1.50

    Dips $1.50  (chocolate • cherry

    blue raspberry • birthday cake  • cotton candy)


  • Hard Ice Cream

    1 Scoop  $5.23 • 2 Scoops  $6.48

    3 Scoops  $7.64


    Vanilla • Chocolate

    Coconut Chocolate Almond

    Moose Tracks • Cookies & Cream

    Brownie Batter • Butter Pecan

    Dark Chocolate Raspberry Truffle 

    Salty Caramel Truffle • Berry Acai

    Cappuccino Crunch  Cotton Candy

    Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough

    P.B. Caramel Cookie Dough

    Graham Central Station

    Green Mint Chip 


    Dairy-Free Vegan Hard Ice Cream

    one scoop $5.74  •  two $6.76  •  three $7.73

  • Sundaes

    Mix+Match any 2 below

    reg $6.76 large $7.92

    Hot Fudge • Caramel • Coconut

    Blueberry • Cherry • Strawberry • Pineapple • Raspberry • Nutella

    Peanut Butter • Marshmallow


    Specialty Sundaes - Large $9.63

    Butter Pecan • Oreo • Mexican • Butterfinger • Fudge Brownie

    Snickers • Black Forest • Turtle

    Hot Banana • Peanut Butter Cup

    M&M's • Shortcake Bites


    - Extras -

    chopped/spanish nuts $1.10

    pecans/pistachios/walnuts $1.50

    waffle $2.35 •  sugar bowl $1.60 

    hard ice cream $1.90

    custard/dole $1.10


    Trash Can Sundae   soft vanilla, chocolate sauce, oreos, whipped cream, candy eyes, and gummy worms in a toy can  $9.58


    Spaghetti Sundae   frozen whip cream 'pasta' with soft vanilla, strawberry 'sauce' & malted chocolate 'meatballs'  $9.58

  • Milkshakess

    Reg $5.60  •  Lg $7.27  •  Giant $8.70


    Chocolate • Vanilla • Strawberry

    Rootbeer • Coffee • Cherry • Banana Blueberry • Pineapple

    Red Raspberry • Black Raspberry

    Add Malt $1.10


    Try it with Fresh Fruit! $1.10   Strawberry • Banana • Pineapple • Raspberry • Blueberry • Cherry

  • Polar Storms

    Peter's take on the classic flurry!

    Regular $6.30  •  Large  $7.55


    Peanut M&M's • Peanut Butter Cup

    Cookie Dough • M&M's • Heath

    Cake Batter • Brownie Batter

    Snickers • Reese's Pieces • Nerds

    Marshmallow • Oreo • Fresh Fruit

    Butterfinger

  • Specialty Treats

    Dole Whip Parfait   dole whip with soft serve vanilla  $4.86


    Fresh Fruit Parfait 

    with soft serve vanilla  $7.55


    Polar Patties    vanilla / chocolate / twist sandwiches  $2.50

    (Buy 4 + Get 2 FREE!)  Call ahead to get other flavors made to order


    Polar Pops - vanilla / chocolate / twist on a stick  $3.89

     

    Shark Attack  blue raspberry slush + soft vanilla + gummy sharks + cherry juice  $6.20


    Banana Split    small $8.89  •  large $10.28  •  giant 19.54


    Banana Pop  $2.73 • w/nuts or sprinkles $3.52


    Grab Bag  a pair of mystery treats in a bag  $5.37 


    Doggie Sundae   kiddie bowl of vanilla + a dog biscuit    $2.96

  • Chill Drinks

    Slushies - orange • cherry • grape • watermelon • blue raspberry • lemon lime • bubble gum •  green apple • cotton candy  • the shocker

    kiddie $2.50 • small $3.06 • reg $3.52 • Lg. $4.68


    Glaciers  soft serve vanilla + your favorite slush

    kiddie $2.59  • small $3.10 • reg $4.03• Lg. $5.93


    Hawaiian Freeze -or-

    Rainbow Sherbet Cooler

    small $4.07 • reg $5.79 • Lg. $7.27


    Ice Cream Sodas & Floats

    reg $4.95 • Lg.  $7.18


    Fountain Soda

    kid $1.48  •  sm $2.36  •  reg $2.87

     large $3.52  •  giant $3.98


    Spring Water  $2.04

  • Ice Cream Pies + More

    Ice Cream Pies   made right in house with a graham crust  $25


    Hot Fudge Sundae • Carmel Fudge Turtle Delight • Heavenly Heath • Seriously Snickers • Positively Peanut Butter • Oh So Oreo • Walnut Brownie Supreme


    Pumpkin Ice Cream Pies

    available in season   $27


    Take Home Soft Serve   by the pint $8.24  •   by the quart $10.83


    Take Home Hard Ice Cream  by the pint $11.85  •   by the quart $13.75

  • Soft Ice Cream

    Kiddie        $3.01  •  Small     $3.89

    Medium    $4.49  •  Large     $5.88


    Vanilla +  Chocolate

    Pistachio +  Old Fashioned Custard

    Black Raspberry + Raspberry Dole

    Blueberry + Lemon Dole

    Vanilla + Orange Dole


    Get any above twisted with the paired flavor!

    Maple • Pumpkin available in season

    Dole Whips are DAIRY-FREE!!


    Sugar Cone 75¢ • Waffle Cone $1.40

    Sprinkles $1.10 • Krunch Kote  $1.50

    Dips $1.50  (chocolate • blue raspberry

    birthday cake  • cotton candy • cherry)


  • Hard Ice Cream

    One Scoop  $5.23 • Two $6.48 • Three $7.64


    Vanilla • Chocolate • Coconut Chocolate Almond

    Moose Tracks • Cookies & Cream • Brownie Batter

    Dark Chocolate Raspberry Truffle • Butter Pecan

    Salty Caramel Truffle • Cappuccino Crunch

    Peanut Butter Caramel Cookie Dough

    Graham Central Station • Berry Acai

    Cotton Candy • Green Mint Chip 

    Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough


    Dairy-Free Vegan Hard Ice Cream

    one scoop $5.74  •  two $6.76  •  three $7.73

  • Sundaes

    Mix+Match any 2 below   reg $6.76 large $7.92

    Hot Fudge • Hot Caramel • Blueberry • Cherry

    Strawberry • Pineapple • Raspberry • Nutella

    Peanut Butter • Marshmallow • Coconut


    Specialty Sundaes - Large $9.63

    Butter Pecan • Oreo • Mexican • Butterfinger

    Fudge Brownie • Snickers • Black Forest

    Hot Banana • Peanut Butter Cup

    M&M's • Turtle • Shortcake Bites


    - Extras - chopped/spanish nuts $1.10

    pecans/pistachios/walnuts $1.50

    hard ice cream $1.90 • custard/dole $1.10

    waffle bowl $2.35  • sugar bowl $1.60 


    Trash Can Sundae   soft vanilla, chocolate sauce, oreos, whipped cream, candy eyes, and gummy worms in a take-home toy can  $9.58


    Spaghetti Sundae   frozen whip cream 'pasta' with vanilla soft serve, strawberry 'sauce'

    & malted chocolate 'meatballs'  $9.58

  • Milkshakes


    Regular $5.60  •  Large $7.27  •  Giant $8.70


    Chocolate • Vanilla • Strawberry • Rootbeer

    Coffee • Cherry • Banana • Blueberry • Pineapple

    Red Raspberry • Black Raspberry • Add Malt $1.10


    Try it with Fresh Fruit! $1.10   Strawberry • Banana

    Pineapple • Raspberry • Blueberry • Cherry

  • Polar Storms

    Peter's take on the classic flurry!

    Regular $6.30  •  Large  $7.55


    Peanut M&M's • Peanut Butter Cup

    Cookie Dough • M&M's • Butterfinger 

    Cake Batter • Brownie Batter • Heath

    Snickers • Reese's Pieces • Nerds

    Marshmallow • Oreo • Fresh Fruit

  • Specialty Treats

    Dole Whip Parfait   dole whip with soft serve vanilla  $4.86

    Fresh Fruit Parfait   with soft serve vanilla  $7.55


    Polar Patties   soft serve vanilla/chocolate/twist sandwiches  $2.50

    (Buy 4 + Get 2 FREE!)  Call ahead to get other flavors made to order

    Polar Pops - vanilla/chocolate/twist on a stick  $3.89

     

    Shark Attack  blue raspberry slush + soft serve vanilla

    with gummy sharks and cherry juice  $6.20


    Banana Split    small $8.89  •  large $10.28  •  giant 19.54


    Banana Pop  $2.73 • w/nuts or sprinkles $3.52

    Grab Bag  a pair of mystery treats in a bag  $5.37 

    Doggie Sundae   kiddie bowl of vanilla + a dog biscuit    $2.96

  • Chill Drinks

    Slushies - orange • cherry • grape • watermelon

    blue raspberry • lemon lime • bubble gum

    green apple • cotton candy  • the shocker

    kiddie $2.50 • small $3.06 • reg $3.52 • Lg. $4.68


    Glaciers  soft serve vanilla + your favorite slush

    kiddie $2.59  • small $3.10 • reg $4.03• Lg. $5.93


    Hawaiian Freeze -or- Rainbow Sherbet Cooler

    small $4.07 • reg $5.79 • Lg. $7.27


    Ice Cream Sodas & Floats - reg $4.95 • Lg.  $7.18


    Fountain Soda     kid $1.48  •  small $2.36

    regular $2.87  •  large $3.52  •  giant $3.98


    Spring Water  $2.04

  • Ice Cream Pies + More

    Ice Cream Pies   made right in house with a graham crust  $25

    Hot Fudge Sundae • Carmel Fudge Turtle Delight • Heavenly Heath • Seriously Snickers • Positively Peanut Butter • Oh So Oreo • Walnut Brownie Supreme


    Pumpkin Ice Cream Pies   available in season   $27


    Take Home Soft Serve   by the pint $8.24  •   by the quart $10.83


    Take Home Hard Ice Cream  by the pint $11.85  •   by the quart $13.75

GALLERY OF SWEETNESS

GET YOUR PHOTO FEATURED HERE!

EMAIL US
A black and white silhouette of a trumpet on a white background.

BE THE FIRST!

Know when special flavors drop

Contact Us

A black and white drawing of a basket of apples and an orange.

TRY BIG DIP!

OUR SISTER STORE

Route 11  •  North Syracuse

THERE'S NONE BIGGER
A black and white silhouette of an ice cream cone on a white background.

and  SNO TOP!

OUR NEWEST LOCATION

315 Fayette St  •  Manlius

CHECK OUT THE TOP!
A group of people are sitting at tables outside of a pizza parlor.

FREQUENTLY ASKED

QUESTIONS

  • Do you take credit cards?

    Absolutely.

  • What are your specialties?

    Dole Whip parfaits, Trash cans, Glaciers, and more... absolute rarities and some one-of a kind treats!  For a full list, and descriptions of each, browse our menu under "specialty treats'  --you're sure to find something that sparks your interest :) 

  • Do you make ice cream pies?

    We sure do! Just give us a call 24 hours in advance and we'll make anything that strikes your fancy, custom made to order!

  • Do you offer any vegan options?

    We always have at least one vegan ice cream option available! (chocolate chunk, cookie dough chip, or classic cookie) --Plus... Italian ice, frozen chocolate bananas, slushies as well as our Dole Whip flavors, Dole Whip blast, Dole Whip glacier, Blue moon, Cactus cooler and Frozen Lemonade!

Peter's transparent logo

All Rights Reserved • Powered by the 315